5 thoughts on “Do religious services really honour the Anzac ethos?

  1. Milton David Fisher

    Dear Chrys,

    I appreciate your essay very much. Christian religious services are inappropriate for two of the men who were there. Simpson was an atheist, and Monash was a Jew. I wrote something about Anzac Day also.

    https://www.onlineopinion.com.au/view.asp?article=17285

    My objection to Anzac Day is as follows:

    “I am writing this article in reaction to ANZAC day. I think it would be a more suitable way to remember the 62,000 and the many others killed in Australia’s wars to try to lessen the possibility of future wars rather than have dawn services, parades, speeches and monuments.”

    I have followed your writings with interest and appreciation. I am now 96 and amazed to be still be alive. Perhaps you remember me.

    David Fisher

    Reply
  2. Richard Gielingh

    proxy church service,stopped going because of that.Still have full respect for those men at Gallipoli.

    Reply
  3. Pat Pendrey

    As a formerly ordained person and long since non-believer, I couldn’t agree more. I vividly recall the unseemly jockeying carried out by the more evangelical of my former colleagues to snag the podium for the local ANZAC day events and oh, how they would waffle on! Those of us of the more catholic end of the spectrum (NB little ‘c’) while happy enough to attend in support were only too glad to leave it to the RSL, service personnel etc. Its not the place for proselytising. Its a time to stand in silent solidarity with the grieving.

    Reply
    1. thatsmyphilosophy Post author

      I had a similar story conveyed to me by a member of the clergy this week. The religious co-option of Anzac Day is also unpopular with many inside the church.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s